| Character | Actor |
|---|---|
| Juror #1 | Martin Balsam |
| Juror #2 | John Fiedler |
| Juror #3 | Lee J. Cobb |
| Juror #4 | E.G. Marshall |
| Juror #5 | Jack Klugman |
| Juror #6 | Edward Binns |
| Juror #7 | Jack Warden |
| Juror #8 | Henry Fonda |
| Juror #9 | Joseph Sweeney |
| Juror #10 | Ed Begley |
| Juror #11 | George Voskovec |
| Juror #12 | Robert Webber |